One good knife or a knife block?

Close on money. Not close in the kitchen: most cooks use one knife from a block of six, and it is dull.

Knife block setOne good chef's knife
Up frontA block of five or six knivesOne chef's knife, plus a honing steel
Used dailyOne or two of the sixThe one
SharpnessSoft steel that won't hold an edgeTakes and keeps an edge; sharpened a few times a year
SpaceA block on the worktopA drawer slot or a magnetic strip
LifespanReplaced when they get too dull to bother withDecades

The sum

Over 10 years, roughly: Knife block set £90 · One good chef's knife £100.

Assumes a budget block replaced every four years, against one knife and a steel with an occasional professional sharpen. Typical UK prices, rounded.

Open this in the cost-per-year calculator and put in your own numbers.

When the other one wins

A serrated bread knife and a small paring knife are worth having too. Past those three, most extra knives are for drawers, not cooking.

What we recommend