Second-hand first

The things worth buying once are the same things worth buying used: a cast iron pan, a good coat, a welted boot, a steel watch. They were made to outlast their first owner. Here is where to look, what to check, and when to walk away.

Where to look

What to check

Cast iron and carbon steel pans

  • Set it on a flat surface and press the edges: it shouldn't rock. A warped pan heats unevenly.
  • Look for cracks, especially from the rim down and around the handle. A crack is the end of the pan.
  • Rust, sticky old oil and burnt-on crust are all fine: they come off with a scrub and a reseason.

Skip anything cracked or badly warped. Everything else can be brought back.

How to bring it back · Lodge cast iron skillet, 10.25 inch · de Buyer Mineral B carbon steel frying pan, 28cm

Enamelled cast iron pots

  • Look inside for chips in the enamel on the cooking surface; chips on the outside rim are only cosmetic.
  • Staining inside is normal and often cleans up with a soak.
  • Check the lid fits and its knob is tight; replacement knobs are usually sold separately.

Skip a pot with chipped enamel inside, where the bare iron would meet food.

Le Creuset cast iron round casserole · Chasseur cast iron casserole, 28cm

Knives and multi-tools

  • Sight down the blade: it should be straight, with the tip intact.
  • Folding blades and tools should open and close firmly, without wobble when locked.
  • A dull edge doesn't matter; sharpening fixes it. Deep chips take longer but can be ground out.

Skip a bent blade, a broken tip you can't live with, or a loose joint on a locking knife.

How to bring it back · Victorinox Fibrox Pro chef's knife, 8 inch · Opinel No.8 folding knife · Leatherman Wave+ multi-tool · Victorinox Huntsman Swiss Army knife

Boots and shoes

  • Look at where the shoe bends across the toes: deep cracks in the leather there can't be undone.
  • On welted boots, the stitching around the sole should be intact; a worn sole itself is a routine resole.
  • Try them on, or compare the inside length with a pair that fits. Leather moulds to its first owner.

Skip cracked uppers or a broken welt. A worn sole or heel is a reason to bargain, not to walk away.

How to bring it back · Red Wing Iron Ranger boots · Birkenstock Boston clogs

Wool and knitwear

  • Hold it up to the light to spot small holes; moths prefer underarms, collars and folds.
  • Pilling is only surface fibre and comes off with a comb or shaver.
  • Before it goes in your wardrobe, wash it, or seal it in a bag in the freezer for a few days, so nothing comes home with it.

Skip anything with many small holes across it; one or two can be darned.

How to bring it back · Icebreaker merino wool T-shirt · Patagonia Better Sweater fleece jacket

Jackets and coats

  • Run every zip from end to end, and check the pull tabs and poppers.
  • Look at the seams at the shoulders and cuffs, and on rain jackets, whether the inside seam tape is peeling.
  • A waxed jacket that feels dry or smells musty only needs cleaning and re-waxing.

Skip a rain jacket whose inner coating is flaking off in patches; it can't be put back.

How to bring it back · Barbour Bedale waxed cotton jacket · Patagonia Torrentshell 3L rain jacket · Fjällräven Greenland winter jacket

Bags and packs

  • Run every zip and check the stitching where the straps join the bag; that is where they fail.
  • Look inside at the bottom corners for wear holes.
  • Some makers repair their own bags under warranty, sometimes for second owners too. Ask them.

Skip torn strap anchors unless you have a cobbler who will restitch them.

How to bring it back · Fjällräven Kånken backpack · Osprey Farpoint 40 travel pack

Watches

  • Automatic watches: shake gently, it should start; set it and check it over a day. A few seconds out is normal.
  • Look for a cracked crystal and a crown that turns and pulls out cleanly.
  • A quartz watch that has stopped usually only needs a battery.

Skip a watch with water marks under the glass; the movement may be corroded.

How to bring it back · Casio F-91W digital watch · Seiko 5 automatic watch

Fountain pens

  • Look at the nib from the side and from above: the two halves should line up and touch at the tip.
  • Check the body and cap for cracks, especially at the threads.
  • Dried ink is normal; a flush brings most pens back.

Skip a cracked body. A bent nib can often be replaced on its own.

How to bring it back · LAMY Safari fountain pen · Kaweco Classic Sport fountain pen

E-readers

  • Turn it on and look for dead lines or spots on the screen; they don't go away.
  • Ask how long the battery lasts now. Weeks is good; a day or two means it is tired.
  • Make sure the previous owner has signed out and reset it, so it can be set up as yours.

Skip a cracked or patchy screen, or one that is still tied to someone else's account.

Kobo Clara e-reader

Moka pots, cafetières and kettles

  • Moka pots: look at the base for pitting or a bulge, and plan on a new gasket and filter plate anyway.
  • Cafetières: the glass jug and mesh filter are both sold as spares; check the metal frame isn't bent.
  • Kettles: limescale inside comes out with a descale.

Skip a moka pot with a damaged or bulging base; it holds pressure.

How to bring it back · Bialetti Moka Express stovetop coffee maker · Bodum Chambord French press, 8 cup · Hario Buono stovetop kettle, 1 litre

Office chairs

  • Sit and raise the seat to the top: it should stay there all afternoon. A sinking seat needs a new gas lift.
  • Try every lever: seat depth, back tilt, lumbar and arms should all move and lock.
  • Look at the castors, the arm pads and the seat mesh or foam; all are replaceable on the well-known models.

Skip a cracked base or back frame. Worn arm pads and castors are cheap to replace.

Bought something used? Keep it going has care notes for everything we recommend.