Cast iron or non-stick?

Non-stick is lovely for a year or two. Cast iron is awkward for a month and then lasts a lifetime.

Non-stick panCast iron pan
Up frontCheap to mid-pricedAround £35–£50 for a good skillet
LifespanUntil the coating wears, often a few yearsDecades; rust is a surface problem
What wearsThe coating, which cannot be redone at homeThe seasoning, which you rebuild by cooking
WeightLightHeavy
LearningNoneDry it, oil it, and cook with a little fat

The sum

Over 10 years, roughly: Non-stick pan £100 · Cast iron pan £45.

Assumes a mid-priced non-stick pan replaced every three years. Typical UK prices, rounded.

Open this in the cost-per-year calculator and put in your own numbers.

When the other one wins

If lifting a heavy pan is hard for you, a carbon steel pan gives most of the benefits at about half the weight. For eggs every morning, some people keep one small non-stick pan and treat it gently.

What we recommend