| Non-stick pan | Cast iron pan | |
|---|---|---|
| Up front | Cheap to mid-priced | Around £35–£50 for a good skillet |
| Lifespan | Until the coating wears, often a few years | Decades; rust is a surface problem |
| What wears | The coating, which cannot be redone at home | The seasoning, which you rebuild by cooking |
| Weight | Light | Heavy |
| Learning | None | Dry it, oil it, and cook with a little fat |
The sum
Over 10 years, roughly: Non-stick pan £100 · Cast iron pan £45.
Assumes a mid-priced non-stick pan replaced every three years. Typical UK prices, rounded.
Open this in the cost-per-year calculator and put in your own numbers.
When the other one wins
If lifting a heavy pan is hard for you, a carbon steel pan gives most of the benefits at about half the weight. For eggs every morning, some people keep one small non-stick pan and treat it gently.
What we recommend
Lodge cast iron skillet, 10.25 inchPre-seasoned cast iron that gets better with use and can be handed down; no coating to wear off.
de Buyer Mineral B carbon steel frying pan, 28cmBare iron with a beeswax finish: no coating to wear off, it seasons with use and outlasts any non-stick pan.
The longer read: Cast iron, carbon steel or stainless: the pan you buy once
More: Safety razor or cartridge razor? · Moka pot or pod machine? · Rechargeable or disposable batteries? · Fountain pen or disposable pens? · A steel bottle or bottled water? · A menstrual cup or disposables? · An e-reader or paper books? · A good office chair or a cheap one? · Guaranteed wool socks or a multipack? · One good knife or a knife block?